Well, I got it open! I may have gotten some unwitting help from my wonderful combination changing wife however. So, when I bought the lock, there was no combination set - so I set one just so that it would be a functioning lock (all gates were lined up when I got it, so just trying at 2.5 increments around the dial would have opened it!). I decided that since I was really going to delve into this lock, I better have the combination changed to something unknown.
So I proceeded with mapping out the lock again AWL, and got this (I didn't graph all the points after 10, until I got to something interesting):
This showed what looked like an obvious gate at 39 - obvious enough I didn't continue graphing. High-Low showed it to be the third number (more on that later). So I then did a second graph with 1&2AR and 3 parked at 39 which yielded this (only graphed the LCP - the right was considerably harder to pinpoint, and I decided the LCP may be enough):
This did reveal a high spot, but it was much too wide to be a gate. So I decided that since wheel 2 is often the first or second wheel to indicate, that I would park wheel 1 at 50 (the middle of the lowest area), and map wheel 2, which yielded this:
When I got to 37.5 I found a SERIOUS low spot - like 1.25 whole increments low spot. I thought I must have hit the jackpot of all gate signatures, so I started trying to amplify around the 37.5 mark when... the lock opened!!!! Therefore, the lock opened at 50-38-39.
I tried it again just to be sure, and sure enough, it opened. I checked my wife's written combo and that is exactly what it was. I got lucky twice with this lock - first my wife set the last two numbers one digit apart (even though I told her the last time she set a combo for me that they should be at least 10 digits apart for adjacent numbers in the combo - she must have forgotten!), so that is probably why I was able to find a gate with AWL (and probably a more pronounced gate signature than I would otherwise get - there were TWO gates lined up there!) - and not get the weird high spot due to the LaGard oval wheels. Second, I just arbitrarily set the first wheel to 50 since it was the middle of the big wide low spot. I would have still figured it out after I nailed down that the 2nd number was 38, but it was just weird to have it open when I thought I was just amplifying a gate signature.
So... victory for now, but I will have to have her reset it with a better combination.